EDITOR'S NOTE: Ten
years and $2.5 billion in research have found no cures from alternative
medicine. Yet these mostly unproven treatments are now mainstream and
used by more than a third of all Americans. This is one in an
occasional Associated Press series on their use and potential risks.
People looking for natural cures will be happy to know there is one. Two words explain how it works: "I believe."
It's
the placebo effect — the ability of a dummy pill or a faked treatment
to make people feel better, just because they expect that it will. It's
the mind's ability to alter physical symptoms, such as pain, anxiety
and fatigue.
In just the past few weeks, the placebo effect has
demonstrated its healing powers. In tests of a new drug to relieve
lupus symptoms, about a third of patients felt better when they got
dummy pills instead of the drug.
The placebo effect looms large
in alternative medicine, which has many therapies and herbal remedies
based on beliefs versus science. Often the problems they seek to
relieve, such as pain, are subjective.
"It has a pejorative
implication — that it's not real, that it has no medicinal value," said
Dr. Robert Ader, a psychologist at the University of Rochester in New
York who has researched the phenomenon.
But placebos can have real and beneficial effects, he said.
"Much
of the results of certain alternative procedures are largely placebo
effects, unless you believe there are people who exert magical powers
so they can hold their hands over your body and cure you of disease,"
Ader said. "Make you feel better? That's entirely possible, especially
if you believe it."
The placebo effect accounts for about a third
of the benefits of any treatment — even carefully tested medicines,
scientists say. This dates to a landmark report in 1955 called The
Powerful Placebo. Viewed as groundbreaking, the analysis of dozens of
studies by H.K. Beecher found that 32 percent of patients responded to
a placebo.
Later studies found that dummy pills could raise pulse
rates, blood pressure and reaction speed when people were told they had
taken a stimulant; the opposite occurred when people were told that a
drug would make them drowsy.
How does it work? Scientists do not
always know, but there are many possible ways. Brain imaging shows that
beliefs ("I know these pills will help") can cause biological changes
and affect levels of chemical messengers and stress hormones that
signal pain or pleasure.
Emotions, too, can trigger physical
changes. Take the case of a child with croup. Crying tightens the
airways and makes it tougher to breathe. Many people believe that cool
mist is helpful, but when it has been tested in hospital studies with
croup tents, it has not been found to help, said Dr. Owen Hendley, a
pediatrician at the University of Virginia.
Try it at home, though, and you may get a different result.
"The
child sits in the lap of the mother and the mother holds the mist maker
close to the child. The child settles down, the mother settles down.
The setting, and the mother feeling that it is helping, makes everybody
calmer," and the child actually is able to breathe better, Hendley
explained.
If it were not for the placebo effect, "physicians
would not be nearly as successful as we are," said Dr. Thomas
Schnitzer, a Northwestern University arthritis specialist. He helped
lead a big study that found glucosamine and chondroitin supplements
were no better than dummy pills for arthritic knee pain.
Doctors
sometimes exploit the placebo effect to help patients. One survey found
that many doctors admitted sometimes giving patients sugar pills or
drugs or vitamins that would not really help their condition, in an
effort to trigger a placebo effect.
In Baltimore, the University
of Maryland Medical Center's shock trauma center is offering some
patients Reiki therapy, which claims to heal through invisible energy
fields manipulated by a special "master." The hospital's anesthesia
chief, Dr. Richard Dutton, says it is self-hypnosis and compares it to
Lamaze classes that teach pregnant women breathing exercises to take
their minds off the pain of labor.
Roy A. Armstrong's family
agreed to it after he was injured in a motorcycle crash last year. The
39-year-old suffered cardiac arrest and had many broken bones. As he
lay tethered to a breathing machine, nurse Donna Audia and a partner
circled his bed, waving their arms through the air and touching his
head while humming and making tunes by rubbing a crystal bowl with a
wand.
Armstrong was too sedated to remember anything, but "I
think in some way it helped him to get better," his wife said. He is
still recovering through physical therapy.
Dutton said: "You can
call it a placebo effect, you can call it a chicken soup effect. It's
all about creating the right mental state in the person. The patients
tell us they seem to like it. And in pain management, that's the whole
goal. If 30 percent of your patients get better on placebo, why not
give it to them?"
Swear-by-it stories and anecdotal reports of
benefit are one thing. Proving a treatment helps is quite another. Many
alternative medicine studies have not included a placebo group — people
who unknowingly get a dummy treatment so its effect can be compared.
Acupuncture
is especially hard to research. Positive studies tend to lack
comparison groups that have been given a sham treatment. Or they are
often done in China, where the treatment is an established part of
health care.
One U.S. study found that true acupuncture relieved
knee arthritis pain better than fake acupuncture, in which guide tubes
were placed but no needles were inserted. But a European study
involving twice as many patients and using a more realistic sham
procedure found the fake treatment to be just as good. The conclusion:
Pain relief was due to the placebo effect.
Advertisements and
testimonials from product users can encourage a placebo effect. The
Federal Trade Commission last summer reached a settlement over
advertising claims for Airborne, a product "invented by a teacher" that
was supposed to ward off germs spread through the air.
"Products
like Airborne are what we call 'credence products.' That's a fancy word
for saying it's difficult or impossible for consumers to determine if
the product has done anything for them," said commission lawyer Rich
Cleland. "Part of that is because of the placebo effect. Part of that
is because people don't want to believe they've been ripped off."
Barbara
Domen, a former kindergarten teacher in Caswell Beach, N.C., said she
was prone to colds and used Airborne six or seven times a year when she
flew on planes.
"It worked for me," although it could be because
since she retired, "I'm away from all the germs," she said. She skipped
it on one flight and caught a terrible cold.
"Maybe it's psychological, but I think I'll continue to use it," she said.
Some
placebo effects are due to conditioning, or ascribing benefits to
something you did that may in fact have played no role in your
improvement. Insomnia is an example, said Michael Perlis, a
psychologist and neuroscientist at the University of Pennsylvania.
If
you have trouble sleeping one night, your body's need for sleep makes
it very likely you'll sleep well the next night. If you take a sleeping
pill, you think you slept well because of the pill, he said.
Do
any herbal remedies work for insomnia? "Not that I know of," Perlis
said. "But all of them have potential to be useful with time. It has
nothing to do with them — it has everything to do with conditioning."